PHONE: 800-882-1415 HOURS: 8am - 5pm

Report a Claim


During hours

Claim service is a very important part of our service to you. Each of the companies that we write with have a team of experienced claim staff that is ready to help in case a loss should occur. If a claim should occur during our regular business hours of 8 AM to 5PM, Monday thru Friday, please call the office immediately at 800-882-1415 and one of our claim staff will assist you in reporting your loss. In the event our office is closed, please dial one of the “after hours” phone numbers listed below for the appropriate company to report your claim.

After hours: 5:00 pm to 8:00 am

To file an after hours claim contact:

  • 1st Choice: 1-800-326-4968
  • AIC: 1-800-841-5241
  • Allied: 1-800-282-1446
  • American Collectors: 1-800-360-2277 till 7 pm
  • Amerisafe: 1-800-699-6240
  • Brethren Mutual: 1-800-241-2541
  • Buildersrisk: 1-800-987-3373
  • Cumberland Insurance: 1-866-794-6399
  • Everett Cash Mutual: 1-800-326-4968
  • FirstComp: 1-888-500-3344 till 7 pm
  • Foremost: 1-800-527-3907
  • Goodville Mutual: 1-877-445-5780
  • Lebanon Mutual: 1-800-514-6072 (leave a message)
  • Lititz Mutual: 1-855-725-5642
  • Progressive: 1-800-274-4499
  • SWIF: 1-888-388-7943
  • Westfield Insurance: 1-866-937-2663
  • Westfield Defender: 1-866-937-2663